Holding My Own in No Man's Land: Women and Men and Film and Feminists

3.2/5 ( ratings)

Molly Haskell, one of America's leading film critics, has been delighting readers for decades with her intelligence and insight. Her landmark book, From Reverence to Rape: The Treatment of Women in the Movies, praised for its wit and style and called a valuable contribution to film
scholarship, is still considered among the most stimulating and important books on the subject of women and film. In Holding My Own in No Man's Land, a series of pieces written in the twenty years since the publication of From Reverence to Rape, Haskell once again explores the relationship between
women and men, and between the movies and those who watch them.
Haskell remains a controversial figure in both feminist and film circles, accused of uncritically celebrating heterosexual romance--a charge to which Haskell cheerfully pleads guilty. Holding My Own In No Man's Land challenges the conventional feminist wisdom that the classic films of the
Thirties, Forties, and Fifties were made by a male-dominated industry which reduced women to objects of the male gaze. Instead, she says that women were better served by the notoriously tyrannical studio system than they are in the newer, freer, hipper Hollywood of the present. A fascinating
interview with Doris Day points out that, despite her current image as a symbol of all that was repressive about the suburban Fifties, she played a series of roles as--and was herself--a successful career woman who worked because she enjoyed it. In another perceptive portrait, Haskell describes the
mesmerizing power the sultry, self-parodying sex symbol Mae West had on screen, and the financial clout she had off screen. And she writes about Howard Hawks's screwball comedies, such as His Girl Friday and Man's Favorite Sport from the Thirties, where assertive women were equal to men, and more
than held their own in the battle of the sexes.
Holding My Own in No Man's Land ranges from interviews with Hollywood legends such as Gloria Swanson and John Wayne, to celebrations of the comic verve of Lucille Ball and Carol Burnett, to ruminations on literary figures such as Truman Capote and his Holly Golightly, and Jane Austen's Emma. We
learn that the cleaning woman of The Carol Burnett Show logo was a reminder of the days when Burnett and her grandmother, out of spoons and relief money, worked nights as cleaning women in the Warner executive offices. We see Meryl Streep hiding in the spotlight in a refreshingly skeptical
analysis of Streep's determination to be an actress rather than a star. Finally, Haskell closes with a wickedly funny section on recent fashion and style, including pieces on Lipstick Envy and Nude With Attitude.
Haskell describes Holding My Own in No Man's Land as a kind of continuing set of ruminations, encounters, insights, and images of people and characters who have had an influence on our lives. With wit and style she illuminates the hopes and fears we project onto these larger-than-life figures--
the grand dames, the stoic heroes, the dueling couples--and the lessons we learned from them about how to fall in love, how to act as adults, and how to live in this complex world.