Join today and start reading your favorite books for Free!
Rate this book!
Write a review?
This solid fantasy from Judith Tarr blends the Song of Roland with the Arthurian legend to create something new. I've been burned out on King Arthur since I was a teenager, but I love tales about Charlemagne and Roland, so that was the biggest draw for me--and also the dominant element in the story. There's a classic fantasy feel to the book, great in terms of the voice, but the villains felt a bit one-note to me. I did like how Roland evolved in the course of the story. When someone is destined...
To some extent, this is pretty standard fantasy. The dark vs. the light, and let's throw in the grail to spice things up a bit, and hey, have some battles and a pretty lady. Hell. Let's have nine pretty ladies. And some sex. To spice up our hero, he can do magic and he has yellow eyes!On the other hand, there's something unique about this because it actually draws on a lot of medieval myth. Using Arthurian myth isn't all that startling, but I've never seen any of that which also draws on The Son...
At first I wasn't into the book, but after the first couple chapters it got to be pretty good. About half way through there's a twist and it's because of that twist that I really liked this book. It was a reminder of how talented Tarr is and why I just can't get enough of her writing.
So happy to spend some more time in Arthurian Legend!! Really enjoyed this book. The only reason it didn't get 5 stars from me is because it's competing with Stephen Lawhead's Pendragon Cycle...and that's some epic stuff right there. :)
In The Kingdom of the Grail, Tarr has created a story that is a thoroughly enjoyable blend of Arthurian legend and the tales of the court of Charlemagne, two of the three canonical subject mattes for medieval storytellers, as named by French poet Jean Bodel: “Ne sont que iii matières à nul homme atandant, De France et de Bretaigne, et de Rome la grant.” In creating a tale with roots in both traditions, Tarr makes use of the great French epic, La Chanson de Roland, while drawing considerable back...
I loved this book, nice fantasy world to step into. (Helped with my Harry Potter withdraw:) I have always loved the stories around Merlin and Camelot. "Centuries after the fall of Camelot and the disappearance of King Arthur,the wizard Merlin remained a prisoner in a enchanted forest.Then an ardent youth named Roland came and vowed to free him, unaware of the consequences such an oath carried..."
I like the premise of combining the Song of Roland with the grail legend. But in practice, it comes off sounding forced with too little character development. Too much contrived magic, not enough realistic historical description. Too much Roland, not enough Merlin (Why did that dude disappear after the first 10 pages?). In all honesty, there is too much good fantasy out there to make this a worth while read.
Very enchanting story - so many of the elements in this story "ring true", especially the spiritual stuff. Wow - what a great storyteller! I found this at the library and loved the book so much, I purchased a copy. It lifted me up whenever I felt cut off from my true self - that is a rare gift. Thanks, Judith Tarr.
If there is anything I expect from a book, this one lives up to all expectations. I would recommend this book to anyone who loves fantasy and historical fiction. Based on the epic poem of Roland along with heavy influence of the Grail ...and Merlin.
I really wanted to LOVE this story, but I had mixed feelings. I love Judith Tarr’s fantasies and this had the promise of a great story with Merlin and Roland and the grail. The idea was fantastic and the legend of Roland was made for fantasy. Ms. Tarr’s characterizations were superb and a nice twist to the legends, and very cleverly done. Loved the characters. I’m surprised more stories like this haven’t been written. It fits in nicely with the whole grail myth cycle. Unfortunately, the first ha...
Beautiful historical fantasy focusing on the roles of Roland and Sarissa in the Arthurian legend. Tarr's writing flows easily and there's several excellent plot twists to keep the narrative moving along. Slightly shallow in its character development or it would've merited 5 stars.
I really enjoyed how the author combined the Arthurian Grail Quest with the Song of Roland. The story recognizes and honors the Christian faith, the Muslim faith, and the ancient Celtic beliefs without disparaging any of them. The story was entertaining and moved along at a good pace.
Pieces of the Arthurian legend, linked to the Song of Roland, grounded with some historical events, and wrapped together author Judith Tarr's unique imagination--what could be better?
This is a very quiet book, I loved it so much.
The writing in this book made me so angry that I sought comfort in shared commiseration. I did a Google search for "Judith Tarr terrible" and nothing was coming up. I went to Amazon.com reviews, but the few reviews on there were written by her pre-exisiting fans. I came here to Goodreads and most of the reviews were positive. (So there you have it, I will admit that other people do not seem so bothered by the writing; maybe I am just too critical). BUT YOU GOTTA BELIEVE ME, THE WRITING IS TERRIB...
It proved to be a very entertaining story with several unexpected twists. Granted it was clearly a variation on the old story of a brilliant somewhat magical knight meets the unexpected gorgeous priestess falls in love with her after fighting it for a while (the fight being mutual) and going on some magical/spiritual journey that ends in...you get the idea, but it still had enough twists to lift it above cliche status. Also, Judith Tarr writes in my opinion brilliant straight forward prose that
[3 and 1/2 stars]Based on the "Song of Roland" (and throwing some Arthurian stuff into the mix for good measure), this is a very solid effort from Tarr. I think that her medieval fantasies tend to be the best of all her historical fantasies, so that aspect was a pleasure to read (I certainly found the parts that were more solidly rooted in history to be more interesting than the later parts where the action transferred elsewhere and the story became straight-out fantasy.) Still, she displays her...
I really loved this book because it was fantasy and about Arthurian legend. Fantasy is my favorite genre and this book totally fit the bill. I loved the way the book followed the story of Roland and the quest for the grail, but also had a romantic twist in it, too. I would totally recommend this for anyone who is a fan of Arthurian legend and/or fantasy. And... since I loved this novel so much, I went out and bought another Tarr book; The Pride of Kings. I can't wait to read it!
While not a straight-forward historical narrative like Ars Magica, and not entirely realistic speculative writing like Pillar of Fire, Kingdom of the Grail is doing a fantastic job at writing the bridge between early Christianity, Arthurian Legends, and the life of Charlemagne (and the Song of Roland) without skimping on facts, and filling in the gaps with fantasy that doesn't need a full suspension of disbelief.
Amazing!This is an excellent book. A story of light versus dark, woven with beautifully scripted battles, and joyous love scenes. This book lays a land before the reader and guides them on an adventure that they won't be able to turn away from. I recommend this to any and all who wish to get lost in a fantastic book.
This appeals to the 'player of World of Warcraft' in me. The story is about the son of Merlin, Roland and his quest to free Merlin from the enchanted forest. Interesting facts about the round table and the "real" story behind Merlin and where he came from and why he was imprisioned. Interesting
Interesting and beautifully written story of Merlin and what happened after Camelot. Missed most of the allegorical and mythological (not the right word exactly but hey) references but still a nice tale.
I only give five stars to books that I a)like a LOT b)am willing to give shelf space to/actually own c)want to re-read many times - this one meets all three. It is one of the best alternate-Song of Roland stories I've ever read.
Another excellent story from Judith Tarr, she has a true gift for description. Makes me feel like I'm almost there.
I love Merlin stories - this is a good one, enjoyable read.
Very well written and a great heroic tale.
This book was a little slow in building up to things, and I just couldn't really get into it.
Great read...Entertaining story and characters that keep you coming back.
Song of Roland historical fiction bits were fun.
Another great Arthurian tale. Love my King Arthur.